- Frank Coyle's Blog
- College Football Mondays
- Ahead of the Curve
- NFL News
- College News
- Order Publication
Browns Select Josh Gordon in NFL Supplemental Draft 2012
The Cleveland Browns drafted Baylor/Utah wide receiver Josh Gordon in the 2nd round of the NFL 2012 Supplemental Draft this week. It was a shocking early selection for the Browns who forfeit next year’s #2 selection as a result of the addition of Gordon. He is a major reach this early and a prospect who I rated a 3rd day selection in a seven round April draft class. His grade was a marginal Top 100-125 ranking with some serious developmental and off the field issues.
Gordon was the only one of the eight players eligible for the Supplemental Draft that was selected. Carson Newman linebacker Larry Lumpkin signed with the Colts shortly afterwards while TCU running back Ed Wesley will likely signed with an NFL team as an undrafted free agent if his shoulder passes a club’s medical exam. The others players that were eligible were Boise State defensive back Quaylon Ewing, Syracuse fullback Adam Harris, Iowa State offensive lineman Adrian Haughton, Georgia defensive end Montez Robinson and McMurray wide receiver Houston Tuminello. They are free to sign with any NFL team, though rosters are basically filled after mini-camps and most clubs would have to release a player to add a new rookie.
The Browns were overly aggressive adding Gordon. They "won" the second pick of each round in the 2012 Supplemental Draft and the only team drafting ahead of them in each round was the Buffalo Bills. The NFL uses a "lottery system" for determining the Supplemental draft order each July.
Gordon certainly shows good size (6’3” 224 lb.) and athleticism to warrant a mid round selection, though many NFL teams are generally conservative in giving up such high picks in the Supplemental draft especially with camp only weeks away. The last time a player was selected as high as the 2nd round in the Supplemental draft came in July 2003 when the Houston Texans selected former Georgia Tech running back Tony Hollings. No one player has been selected in the first round since former Duke quarterback Dave Brown in 1992. Last year, the Raiders used a #3 pick for QB Terrelle Pryor in the mid summer player draft.
Cleveland was very interested in Gordon in this draft class and they would have taken former Baylor receiver Kendall Wright with the #22 overall pick this past April if he was available. They chose former Oklahoma St QB Brandon Weeden at No. 22 and did not address the receiver position until the 4th round with the selection of wideout Travis Benjamin with the #100 overall pick. The Browns have committed to improving their passing game and needed playmakers and look to Gordon to press veterans, second-year pro Greg Little and veterans Josh Cribbs and Mohamed Massaquoi for playing time.
It will be very interesting to see what impact Gordon after only one full season of college football under his belt, will have in the Browns passing game in 2012. Additionally, the talent of recent receiving classes has improved significantly with the emergence of potent NFL passing games and the prospects available with the Browns 2nd round for the NFL Draft 2013 could be far superior to Gordon as a NFL receiver. The Browns pick could be a top 40-50 overall selection next April.
The selection of Gordon could be a huge impact on the current regime with Browns President Mike Holmgren entering his third season with a 9-23 record and two last place finished in the AFC North in the books. Their NFL 2012 Draft class in April was their best group of rookies selected in years, though the overall strength of this group will depend on the impact development of rookies, runner Trent Richardson and QB Brandon Weeden in addition to several risky early picks included the selection of Josh Gordon this week.
Frank Coyle is a long time member of the FWAA and voter in College player awards - Heisman, Outland, Nagurski, Lombardi, Thorpe etc for the past 18 years. He writes College Football Mondays weekly during the season. He is a longtime scouting consultant for the Senior Bowl, the nation’s premier postseason All-star game. He does sports radio shows for ESPN, Fox Sports and Sporting News on a year round basis related to College Football especially during the postseason team and All-star Bowl time. He has worked for CBS Sports, NBC Sports, Yahoo and Rivals sports publications and web sites.
Eagles Top NFC Draft Class
Photo – DT Fletcher Cox - Mississippi St
NFL Draft 2012 Mini Review - out next week - Free for Subscribers
NFL Draft 2012 Review - complete master Review includes Rookie class and free agents, Mini Camps results and Veteran Free Agent additions - Available in mid June
Philadelphia Eagles - Grade A
The Eagles had another large draft class with 9 overall choices after trades and compensatory picks. They used their #15 pick in the first round to move up to the #12 overall spot to select defensive lineman Fletcher Cox, a quick explosive defender. They moved up for 4th and 6th round choices in this draft class. Cox was our highest rated defensive lineman in this class and is a highly developed prospect who is ready to compete for immediate NFL starting time. He can be an impact performer here especially as a pass rusher with the versatility to lineup at a few spots in their flexible front four. With their two #2 picks, they chose LB Mychal Kendricks and DE Vinny Curry. Kendricks is an athletic defender with experience both inside and outside. He can be a three down defender at any position in the Eagles 4-3 set with the mobility to cover and the burst to rush the passer. Curry is a tough athlete with fine pass rusher skills, but only average run support. He can be an every down defender in time with improvement to anchor and was great value here. On the 3rd round, they selected QB Nick Foles, a big raw passer with a strong arm, but limited mobility. He has nice upside potential with further development and is a young talented QB prospect the Eagles hope to refine over his early career to press for starting time or command a high ransom in the trade market. He was a reach here in the top 100 selections.
With their 4th round pick, they chose CB Brandon Boykin, a quick cover man who fell off a broken leg at the Senior Bowl. Boykin is a good defender who will compete for the nickel corner role when healthy. He figures to become a core cover man in all their package defenses and addresses a pressing need after the trade of veteran corner Asante Samuel. On the 5th round, they added OT Dennis Kelly, a tall rangy blocker who started three seasons on the outside in the Big Ten. He figures to push for a roster spot at a thin position on this squad after key injuries. On the 6th round, they added WR Marvin McNutt and OG Brandon Washington. McNutt is a big tough receiver with sure hands and good route running. He must prove he can separate at the NFL level, but has the makeup to become a fine possession receiver. Washington is a wide body lineman with experience both inside and outside. He was an underachiever who struggled with conditioning and technique that hurt his final grade. He is a boom bust prospect who can be a definite steal if he improves his work habits and overall technique. With their final selection, they added RB Bryce Brown, a highly rated prospect entering college who played in a few programs and never found his spot in either program. He can be a find here with the talent to surprise as a backup and possibly a 1 A type runner and kickoff returner.
Philadelphia Draft Selections
1 -12 Fletcher Cox, DT, Mississippi St.
2 -14 Mychal Kendricks, LB, California
2 - 27 Vinny Curry, DE, Marshall
3 - 25 Nick Foles, QB, Arizona
4 -28 Brandon Boykin, CB, Georgia
5 -18 Dennis Kelly, OT, Purdue
6 -24 Marvin McNutt, WR, Iowa
6 - 30 Brandon Washington, OG, Miami
7 - 22 Bryce Brown, RB, Kansas St.
Frank Coyle is a long time member of the FWAA and voter in College player awards - Heisman, Outland, Nagurski, Lombardi, Thorpe etc for the past 18 years. He writes College Football Mondays weekly during the season. He is a longtime scouting consultant for the Senior Bowl, the nation’s premier postseason All-star game. He does sports radio shows for CBS, ESPN, Fox Sports and Sporting News on a year round basis related to College and NFL Football especially during the postseason team and All-star Bowl time. He has worked for CBS Sports, NBC Sports, Yahoo and Rivals sports publications and web sites.
NFL Draft Podcast - Tebow and Pro Prospects for 2012
This is a link to a Podcast from Tuesday night - March 20th that Frank Coyle was a guest analyst on the site Draft Countdown produced by Scott Wright, the founder and owner.
We covered topics like Peyton Manning, Tim Tebow, Free agency and of course the prospects for the NFL Draft 2012.
Draft Countdown is an outstanding NFL Draft web site that covers the player process thoroughly with expert scouting information. Go to www.draftcountdown.com
Click or paste link below for Draft Countdown Podcast
Frank Coyle - www.draftinsiders.com
Draft Insiders' Digest - 21st season
Frank Coyle is a long time member of the FWAA and voter in College player awards - Heisman, Outland, Nagurski, Lombardi, Thorpe etc. He writes College Football Mondays weekly during the season. He is a longtime scouting consultant for the Senior Bowl, the nation’s premier postseason All-star game. He does sports radio shows for ESPN, Fox Sports and Sporting News on a year round basis related to College Football especially during the postseason team and All-star Bowl time. He has worked for CBS Sports, NBC Sports, Yahoo and Rivals publications and web sites.
NFL Free Agency 2012 - Top 120 Players
Bucs, Redskins & Bears Make Key Additions of first day of NFL 2012 Free Agency and Trading Market
Free Agents - Unrestricted, Restricted & ‘Street’
No Franchise Players listed
Photo - QB Drew Brees - Saints
March Newsletter has an extensive NFL Free Agency 2012 report - Order Today - Special Packages available - call 1-800-776-1949
NFL Free Agency - Top 120 Players
1 Peyton Manning - QB - Indianapolis
2 Mario Williams - DE - Houston
3 Brandon Carr - CB - Kansas City
4 Carl Nicks - OG - New Orleans
5 Matt Flynn - QB - Green Bay
6 Vincent Jackson - WR - San Diego
7 Red Bryant - DE/DT - Seattle
8 Curtis Lofton - LB - Atlanta
9 Eric Winston - OT - Houston
10 Mike Wallace - WR - Pittsburgh
11 Ben Grubbs - G - Baltimore
12 Carlos Rogers - CB - San Fran
13 Marques Colston - WR - New Orleans
14 Chris Myers - C - Houston
15 Lardarius Webb - CB - Baltimore
16 Stephen Tulloch - LB - Detroit
17 Cortland Finnegan - CB - Tennessee
18 Michael Bush - RB - Oakland
19 Terrell Thomas - CB - N.Y. Giants
20 Brandon Lloyd - WR - St. Louis
21 Tracy Porter - CB - New Orleans
22 Brodrick Bunkley - DT - Denver
23 Jason Jones - DT - Tennessee
24 Jared Gaither - OT - San Diego
25 Reggie Wayne - WR - Indianapolis
26 Scott Wells - C - Green Bay
27 Demetrius Bell - OT - Buffalo
28 Kendall Langford - DE - Miami
29 Evan Mathis - G - Philadelphia
30 Jeremy Mincey - DE - Jacksonville
31 Reggie Nelson - S - Bengals
32 John Abraham - DE - Atlanta
33 Mike Tolbert - RB - San Diego
34 David Hawthorne - LB - Seattle
35 LaRon Landry - S - Washington
36 Paul Soliai - NT - Miami
37 Pierre Garcon - WR - Indianapolis
38 Aaron Ross - CB - N.Y. Giants
39 Robert Meachem - WR - New Orleans
40 Alex Smith - QB - San Francisco
41 Sione Pouha - NT - N.Y. Jets
42 Mario Manningham - WR - N.Y. Giants
43 Cory Redding - DE/DT - Baltimore
44 Laurent Robinson - WR - Dallas
45 Jarret Johnson - LB - Baltimore
46 Antonio Garay - NT - San Diego
47 Martellus Bennett - TE - Dallas
48 Aubrayo Franklin - DT - New Orleans
49 Chad Henne - QB - Miami
50 Peyton Hillis - RB - Cleveland
51 Amobi Okoye - DT - Chicago
52 Mark Anderson - DE - New England
53 Rocky McIntosh - LB - Redskins
54 Randy Moss - WR - Tennessee
55 BenJarvus Green-Ellis - RB - New England
56 Erin Henderson - LB - Minnesota
57 Dwight Lowery - S - Jacksonville
58 Jason Campbell - QB - Oakland
59 Josh Morgan - WR - San Francisco
60 Leroy Hill - LB - Seattle
61 Tim Jennings - CB - Chicago
62 London Fletcher - LB - Washington
63 Richard Marshall - CB - Arizona
64 Cedric Benson - RB - Cincinnati
65 Andre Carter - DE - New England
66 Eric Wright - CB - Detroit
67 Samson Satele - C - Oakland
68 Kyle Orton - QB - Kansas City
69 Derek Landri - DT - Philadelphia
70 Manny Lawson - LB - Cincinnati
71 John Carlson - TE - Seattle
72 Jake Scott - G - Tennessee
73 Jarret Johnson - LB - Ravens
74 Steve Hutchinson - G - Minnesota
75 Trevor Laws - DT - Philadelphia
76 Dan Connor - LB - Carolina
77 E.J. Henderson - LB - Minnesota
78 Dan Koppen - C - New England
79 Luis Castillo - DE - San Diego
80 Joe Mays - LB - Denver
81 Kameron Wimbley - DE - Oakland
82 Geoff Schwartz - G - Carolina
83 Ryan Grant - RB - Green Bay
84 Anthony Collins - OT - Cincinnati
85 Dallas Clark - TE - Colts
86 Chilo Rachal - G - San Fran
87 Brandon Jacobs - RB - Giants
88 Abram Elam - SS - Dallas
89 Kevin Smith - RB - Detroit
90 Kevin Boss - TE - Oakland
91 Jerricho Cotchery - WR - Pittsburgh
92 Joseph Addai - RB - Indianapolis
93 Ronald Bartell - CB - Rams
94 Jacob Tamme - TE - Indianapolis
95 Cedric Griffin - CB - Vikings
96 Jeff Backus - OT - Detroit
97 Jake Ballard - TE - Giants
98 Juqua Parker - DE - Philadelphia
99 Brandon Meriweather - S - Chicago
100 Levi Brown - OT - Cardinals
Brees Heads Record List of Franchise Players
Photo - QB Drew Brees - Saints
A record total of 21 NFL teams used their franchise tags before Monday's deadline. Here are the top free agents who received tags. A record 6 kickers received Franchise tags with 3 WR, 3 DB, 3 DE, 2 RB, 1 QB and no OL.
QB Drew Brees received the only Exclusive Franchise designation which means only the Saints can negotiate with him this offseason. All other franchise tagged players can speak with all clubs, though their current team will be compensated if they do not return to their present team.
Teams had until 4 p.m. ET on Monday to apply the franchise tag on a player and keep his rights for the 2012 season. Here's a team-by-team breakdown:
March Newsletter will have an extensive NFL Combine and Veteran Free Agency 2012 reports. - Order Today - Special Packages available - call 1-800-776-1949
Team / Franchise tag
Arizona Cardinals - DE Calais Campbell
Atlanta Falcons - CB Brent Grimes
Baltimore Ravens - RB Ray Rice
Chicago Bears - RB Matt Forte
Cincinnati Bengals - K Mike Nugent
Cleveland Browns - K Phil Dawson
Dallas Cowboys - LB Anthony Spencer
Denver Broncos - K Matt Prater
Detroit Lions - DE Cliff Avril
x - Indianapolis Colts - DE Robert Mathis
Jacksonville Jaguars - K Josh Scobee
Kansas City Chiefs - WR Dwayne Bowe
New England Patriots - WR Wes Welker
* New Orleans Saints - QB Drew Brees
New York Giants - P Steve Weatherford
Oakland Raiders - S Tyvon Branch
Philadelphia Eagles - WR DeSean Jackson
San Francisco 49ers - S Dashon Goldson
Tampa Bay Buccaneers - K Connor Barth
Tennessee Titans - S Michael Griffin
Washington - TE Fred Davis
x - resigned with current club
* The formula for the exclusive-rights tag is the same as it was in the old collective bargaining agreement between the NFL and its players, meaning Brees is scheduled to earn the average of the top five quarterback salaries in 2012. For that reason, Brees' exact salary won't be calculated until the free-agency period is over this summer.
The franchise figure for QBs in 2012 is between $16 million and $17 million, but that likely will be affected by what happens with any potential Peyton Manning deal.
The Saints' decision to use their tag on Brees adds another chapter to a difficult round of negotiations between the team and their leader. Brees broke Dan Marino's NFL single-season passing record this past season and led New Orleans to its only Super Bowl championship just two years ago.
DraftInsiders.com - Order Today - Special Packages available - call 1-800-776-1949
NFL Draft 2012 First Round Selection Order
Dolphins & Chiefs Win Coin Flips!
NFL Draft 2012 – ‘The Colts are ‘On the Clock’!
Photo – QB Andrew Luck - Stanford
The NFL office held the coin flips for the first round ties at the NFL Combine on Friday. The Dolphins and Chiefs won the coin tosses. Miami will select 8th overall with the Panthers now at the 9th choice of the first round. The Chiefs will now pick 11th overall with the Seahawks holding the 12th choice in the first round. This completes the first round order entering the NFL Trading period in mid March. Two teams, the Patriots and Browns hold two #1 selections after trades during the first round of the NFL Draft 2011 last April.
The Colts hold the first overall selection and are the only team that can negotiate with any prospect in the country. The Colts made major changes with the signing of new GM Ryan Grigson and first year head coach Chuck Pagano this postseason. Grigson was a former Eagles executive who had an excellent track record as a personnel evaluator. He takes over an aging roster that has been an annual playoff club until the poor 2011 season. Pagano was the Defensive Coordinator for the Baltimore Ravens. They have ranked in the top 5 to 10 annually in most key defensive categories.
The top overall selection should be QB Andrew Luck regardless if the Colts retain the pick or trades the selection, most likely within the top ten overall choices. Luck will not throw at the NFL Combine and will wait until later this spring with the Stanford Pro Day set for March 22nd.
First Round Selection Order
# Team - W-L - Opp W-L %
1 Indianapolis - 2-14 - .539
2 St. Louis - 2-14 - .590
3 Minnesota - 3-13 - .559
4 Cleveland - 4-12 - .531
5 Tampa Bay - 4-12 - .551
6 Washington - 5-11 - .477
7 Jacksonville - 5-11 - .500
8 Miami - 6-10 - .504
9 Carolina - 6-10 - .504
10 Buffalo - 6-10 - - .520
11 Kansas City - 7-9 -.512
12 Seattle - 7-9 - .512
13 Arizona - 8-8 - .469
14 Dallas - 8-8 - .473
15 Philadelphia - 8-8 - .488
16 NY Jets - 8-8 - .500
17 Cincinnati (Oakland) - 8-8 - .504
18 San Diego - 8-8 - .516
19 Chicago - 8-8 - .527
20 Tennessee - 9-7 - .461
21 Cincinnati - 9-7 - .492
22 Cleveland (Atlanta) - 10-6 - .480
23 Detroit -10-6 - .535
24 Pittsburgh - 12-4 - .492
25 Denver - 8-8 - .520
26 Houston - 10-6 - .453
27 New England (New Orleans) - 13-3 - .441
28 Green Bay - 15-1 - .457
30 Baltimore -12-4 - .477
31 San Francisco - 13-3 - .449
31 New England - 13-3 - .449
32 NY Giants - 9-7 - .520
Team tie-breaking procedure for the NFL Draft
If two or more clubs are tied in the selection order, the strength-of-schedule tie breaker is applied, subject to the following exceptions for playoff clubs:
1. The Super Bowl winner is last and the Super Bowl loser next-to-last.
2. Any non-Super Bowl playoff club involved in a tie shall be assigned priority within its segment below that of non-playoff clubs and in the order that the playoff clubs exited from the playoffs. Within a tied segment a playoff club that loses in the Wild-Card game will have priority over a playoff club that loses in the Divisional playoff game that in turn will have priority over a club that loses in the Conference Championship game. If two tied clubs exited the playoffs in the same round, the tie is broken by strength of schedule.
If any ties cannot be broken by strength of schedule, the divisional or conference tie breakers, when applicable, are applied. Any ties that still exist are broken by a coin flip.
Frank Coyle is a long time member of the FWAA and voter in College player awards - Heisman, Outland, Nagurski, Lombardi, Thorpe etc for the past 20 years. He writes ‘College Football Mondays’ weekly during the season. He is a longtime scouting consultant for the Senior Bowl, the nation’s premier postseason All-star game. He does sports radio shows for ESPN, Fox Sports and Sporting News on a year round basis related to College Football especially during the postseason team and All-star Bowl time.
NFL Free Agency 2012
Franchise-Tag values by Position
Figures for next season by position and top players who could be impacted. NFL Free Agency begins March 13 - Teams must be under the salary cap by this date.
Photo - QB Drew Brees – Saints
Quarterback: $14.4 million (down from $16.1 million in 2011, $16.4 million in 2010)
Players - Drew Brees, Matt Flynn
Draft Insiders' March Newsletter will have extensive NFL Free Agency Report
Running back: $7.7 million (down from $9.6 million in 2011, $8.2 million in 2010)
Players - Matt Forte, Ray Rice
Wide receiver: $9.4 million (down from 11.4 million in 2011, $9.5 million in 2010)
Players - Dwayne Bowe, DeSean Jackson, Vincent Jackson*, Steve Johnson, Mario Manningham, Wes Welker
Tight end: $5.4 million (down from $7.3 million in 2011, $5.9 million in 2010)
Players - Fred Davis, Jermichael Finley
Offensive line: $9.4 million (down from $10.1 million in 2011, $10.7 million in 2010)
Players - Ben Grubbs, Carl Nicks
Defensive end: $10.6 million (down from $13 million in 2011, $12.4 million in 2010)
Players - Cliff Avril, Calais Campbell, Jason Jones, Mario Williams*, Robert Mathis
Defensive tackle: $7.9 million (down from $12.5 million in 2011. $7 million in 2010)
Players - Red Bryant, Paul Soliai*
Linebacker: $8.8 million (down from $10.1 million in 2011, $9.7 million in 2010)
Players - Stephen Tulloch
Cornerback: $10.6 million (down from $13.5 million in 2011; tag was $9.6 million in 2010)
Players - Cortland Finnegan, Brent Grimes, Brandon Carr, Aaron Ross, Tracy Porter
Safety: $6.2 million (down from $8.8 million in 2011, $6.5 million in 2010)
Players - LaRon Landry, Tyonn Branch, Deshon Goldson
* Player who'd receive more money because it'd be his second year in a row on the franchise tag, meaning he'd make 120 percent of his 2011 salary